The insurance sector is undergoing rapid change, and so are recruiters’ priorities. With AI and automation reshaping underwriting, claims and customer interactions, expectations have expanded far beyond technical knowledge. In 2025, top insurance recruiters seek candidates who combine digital skills, emotional intelligence, diverse perspectives and a growth mindset.
Digital Fluency
According to a Deloitte outlook, prioritizing candidates with digital literacy and AI capabilities is the “top-ranked change” insurance firms are adopting to prepare for AI’s widespread use. Most employers now expect familiarity with platforms like Guidewire, predictive analytics tools or CRM systems.
“Eliminating rote tasks through automation is only the beginning,” said Deloitte: “Insurers will likely need to hire for uniquely human capabilities such as imagination, curiosity, empathy and analytical thinking.” Recruiters increasingly favor candidates who have pursued certifications or upskilling via platforms like Coursera, LinkedIn Learning or internal digital training.
Soft Skills Matter
Despite the tech boom, interpersonal skills remain vital. Recruiters stress that empathy, clarity and composure in high-stress situations matter most. One talent acquisition leader noted that claims professionals frequently interact with clients during difficult times, making patience and understanding just as important as analysis.
Deloitte’s research confirms this shift: recruiters want employees who can “thrive in digital environments—and who are open to learning as platforms evolve.” Engagement with customers via digital and hybrid touchpoints has elevated soft skills to a core competency.
Fresh Perspectives
Expanding the talent pool continues to be a focus for recruiters. According to the Insurance Information Institute, Black professionals made up 14.7% of the insurance workforce in 2024, with claims adjusters and examiners at 20.9%. Women account for about 59% of the industry’s 2.8 million workers.
To strengthen teams and meet evolving business needs, recruiters are engaging with a wider range of institutions and organizations—including HBCUs, veteran networks and re-entry programs. There’s also a growing interest in professionals from outside traditional insurance roles—such as those in tech, customer service or education—who bring valuable insights and transferable skills.
Certifications & Curiosity
Professional credentials, such as CPCU, AIC and ARM, remain valued by recruiters as a means to demonstrate insurance-specific knowledge. But Deloitte emphasizes “curiosity, humility and the willingness to get into the weeds” as equally important traits.
Recruiters appreciate candidates who stay current through MOOCs, industry forums and webinars—especially those exploring AI applications in areas such as underwriting, fraud detection and process mining.
Underwriting & Claims
As insurers adopt AI across underwriting and claims management, recruiters need professionals who understand how it works. Deloitte notes that AI can reduce policy issuance time by up to 80% and help transform traditional workflows.
Companies also emphasize the ethical use of AI, workforce retraining and human oversight, meaning candidates who blend technical fluency with governance awareness gain a competitive edge.
In 2025, insurance recruiters are building teams that are digital‑first, empathetic, diverse and curious. The ideal candidate demonstrates:
- Digital literacy in AI and analytics tools
- Interpersonal strength to support clients in challenging circumstances
- Multifaceted experience that adds depth to team discussions
- Lifelong learning attested by certifications and continued self-education
For those entering or advancing in insurance, the path forward is clear: master the tech, hone the soft skills, embrace multiple perspectives and maintain a growth mindset. In doing so, you meet recruiters’ demands and empower your career to thrive in a swiftly evolving industry.
Read more articles for the ConnectComm Community here.